The Ultimate Ice Cream Trail: 9 Sweet Stops in Seneca County

A Finger Lakes favorite, Cayuga Lake Creamery has been serving homemade ice cream for more than two decades. Known for its rich, creamy flavors, homemade waffle cones, and beautiful outdoor setting, it's the perfect stop while exploring the Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway. With dozens of rotating flavors and seasonal specialties, every visit offers something new to discover.

Don't Miss: One of their homemade waffle cones or a seasonal specialty flavor.

This classic hometown ice cream stand has become a summertime tradition for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving soft serve, hard ice cream, milkshakes, flurries, or sundaes, Village Soft Serve delivers simple, nostalgic treats that make every summer day a little sweeter.

Don't Miss: Their twist cone or one of their creative specialty sundaes.

A beloved seasonal stop in the heart of Romulus, The Ice Cream Stand is the perfect place to cool off after visiting Sampson State Park, touring nearby wineries, or spending the day on Seneca Lake. With classic cones, sundaes, shakes, and soft serve, it's a must-stop for anyone traveling through the area.

Don't Miss: A classic hot fudge sundae or your favorite soft serve flavor.

You never know where you'll spot the Sprinkle Starship next! This charming mobile ice cream truck brings handcrafted frozen treats to community festivals, farmers markets, wineries, weddings, and events across Seneca County. Keep an eye on local event calendars—you might just find your next scoop rolling into town.

Don't Miss: Catching the Starship at one of your favorite local events.

Part grill, part ice cream destination, Border City Cone & Grill is a favorite summer stop for families. After enjoying one of their classic meals, treat yourself to a towering cone, creamy milkshake, or specialty sundae before heading back out to explore the Finger Lakes.

Don't Miss: A towering soft serve cone with your favorite toppings.

Located in the heart of historic downtown Seneca Falls, It's a Wonderful Scoop offers the perfect excuse to slow down and enjoy a sweet treat. After shopping local boutiques or strolling along Fall Street, stop in for one of their many delicious ice cream flavors and enjoy a taste of summer in one of Seneca County's most iconic communities.

Don't Miss: Grab a cone and take a walk through downtown Seneca Falls.

While BB's Hots is known for its comfort food, locals know it's also a great place to cool off with a frozen treat. From creamy soft serve to milkshakes and sundaes, it's the perfect way to finish a meal or enjoy a quick summertime stop.

Don't Miss: Pair your favorite meal with a classic twist cone.

Peppy's is all about classic summer fun. Offering generous portions of soft serve, hard ice cream, specialty sundaes, and frozen treats, this family-friendly shop has quickly become a favorite stop for both locals and visitors looking for a refreshing break on a warm day.

Don't Miss: One of their loaded specialty sundaes or a hand-dipped cone.

No Seneca County ice cream adventure would be complete without a stop at Max's Custard. Famous for its rich frozen custard, freshly made waffle cones, and indulgent sundaes, Max's has become a summertime tradition for generations. Whether you're celebrating a little league win or simply enjoying a sunny afternoon, it's always a sweet stop.

Don't Miss: Fresh frozen custard in a homemade waffle cone.

Why choose just one? Make this summer extra sweet by creating your own Seneca County Ice Cream Trail. Visit each stop throughout the season, pair your favorite treats with nearby parks, lakes, wineries, and downtowns, and discover why ice cream and the Finger Lakes are the perfect combination.

From handcrafted scoops and creamy custard to nostalgic roadside stands and a traveling ice cream truck, there's no shortage of delicious ways to celebrate summer in Seneca County. So grab a cone, hit the road, and savor every stop along the way!